← ALL REGULATORY INTELLIGENCEKNOWLEDGE HUB ↗
FBR21 November 2026 — Chambers publicationS.R.O. 2134(I)/2026 · Draft S.R.O. 2136(I)/2026

How Will FBR’s Faceless Appeals Change Sales Tax and Income Tax Disputes?

Final notification — commencement pendingIncome-tax appeals — draft

FBR has notified a final faceless-appeals chapter for sales tax and federal excise, but commencement is deferred to a Gazette notification. A separate income-tax faceless-appeals chapter remains a draft. The instruments have similar digital procedures, but their legal status and commencement must not be conflated.

Two notifications published by the Federal Board of Revenue on 18 November 2026 address faceless appellate proceedings. S.R.O. 2134(I)/2026 is a final amendment to the Sales Tax Rules, 2006 covering sales tax and federal excise appeals processed through the National Faceless Centre. Draft S.R.O. 2136(I)/2026 proposes a corresponding chapter for income-tax appeals. The first is notified law whose commencement date is still to be specified; the second is not law.

01 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Final notification does not mean immediate commencement

S.R.O. 2134(I)/2026 inserts Chapter XIV-CA, “Faceless Appeals”, comprising rules 150ZZGB to 150ZZGN, into the Sales Tax Rules, 2006. It is a final notification rather than a consultation draft. The commencement clause, however, states that the chapter will come into force on a date the Board specifies by notification in the Official Gazette. The Board may specify different dates for different classes of appeals.

Accordingly, the date printed on the instrument is not the commencement date. Until the commencement notification is located and its scope confirmed, taxpayers should not assume that every appeal is already being handled under the new chapter. The FBR website listing appears to display 17 November, while the downloaded S.R.O. itself is dated 18 November. The Gazette publication date was not independently confirmed in this review; the instrument date is used here without calculating a commencement or consultation deadline from it.

02 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Which sales tax and federal excise appeals are covered?

The chapter applies to appeals under section 45B of the Sales Tax Act, 1990 and section 33 of the Federal Excise Act, 2005 that are processed through the National Faceless Centre under section 45C of the Sales Tax Act. The stated categories include appeals against orders passed by Inland Revenue officers appointed in the Centre and other appeals involving persons, classes of persons, orders or classes of orders that the Board later specifies by Gazette notification.

The coverage therefore depends not only on the tax statute and the impugned order, but also on the Centre’s appointment arrangements and any later notification extending the chapter to other classes. The direct-appeal option to the Appellate Tribunal under the applicable statutory proviso remains unaffected. The chapter does not remove that route or require every aggrieved person to use the faceless first-appeal process.

Appeals already pending before a Commissioner (Appeals) when the chapter becomes applicable continue before that Commissioner unless the Board directs a transfer to the Centre. Where transferred, the record is sent electronically and proceedings continue from the stage already reached. A transfer is therefore not intended, by itself, to restart the entire appeal.

03 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

How independence and allocation are structured

The Centre will have an Appeals Wing comprising Appellate Units, each headed by a Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals). The Appeals Wing is placed under the administrative control of the Member (Legal) Inland Revenue. The Director General, Chief Commissioner or another officer of the Centre is not permitted to control or direct a Commissioner (Appeals) regarding the hearing or decision of an appeal.

An officer who performed audit, assessment or quality-control functions in the case, or who passed the challenged order, cannot hear the appeal. The notified chapter also excludes orders made under it from the quality-control review mechanism in Chapter VIAC. These provisions are distinct safeguards within the new procedure; they do not guarantee that a particular appeal will succeed on its merits.

If a Commissioner (Appeals) has a personal or financial interest, or another connection with the appellant or case, a declaration must be recorded in the system and the appeal reallocated. The Board or Centre may reallocate cases for workload, efficiency, impartiality or conflict reasons. After a hearing has begun, a transfer requires recorded reasons, and the appellant may request a fresh hearing following such transfer.

04 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Electronic filing, evidence and video hearings

Appeals are filed through the Board’s e-portal. On successful filing, the system assigns an appeal number and uses a random, dynamic and automated allocation algorithm to assign an Appellate Unit or Commissioner (Appeals); every allocation is logged. The identity of the Unit and Commissioner is recorded but is not disclosed to the appellant, authorised representative or respondent at any stage, including in the appeal order.

Notices, requisitions, written submissions, arguments, rejoinders and evidence are issued, served and filed electronically. In-person appearances before the Commissioner (Appeals) are excluded; hearings take place by video-conferencing or secure digital links. An appellant may opt for determination on written submissions, but the respondent must be allowed to comment and the appellant must have a right of reply. During a video hearing, the Commissioner’s face is not shown and the voice is modulated to prevent disclosure of identity. Proceedings are recorded and digitally archived as part of the appeal record.

Original documents required by the Commissioner must ordinarily be uploaded as verified scans. The Commissioner may, for recorded reasons, require the original to be produced at a Field Operations Wing unit for verification and an uploaded report. The rules also provide a practical access option: an appellant without internet access may request attendance from the nearest Field Operations Wing e-hearing room, which is to facilitate attendance at the scheduled time.

Where parawise comments are requested, the respondent must upload them within seven days or within any other period allowed by the Commissioner (Appeals). Electronic communication is not merely a convenience: it is the prescribed channel, so the completeness and reliability of the appellant’s e-portal access and record become central to managing the appeal.

05 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Stay applications have a separate timetable

An application for stay of recovery under section 45B(1C) is filed through the e-portal. The system is to fix an e-hearing no later than the second working day after receipt and notify the respondent at the same time. The Commissioner (Appeals) must hear the respondent before deciding the application and must decide it electronically within seven working days of fixation.

The order is communicated on the day it is passed to the appellant, respondent and Field Operations Wing. This is a defined procedural timetable for stay applications, not a statement that recovery automatically stops whenever an appeal or stay request is filed. Taxpayers should identify the statutory recovery position and obtain any protection that the law or a specific order provides rather than rely on the act of filing alone.

06 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Digital orders, deemed service and system failure

Orders, decisions, directions and notices issued under the chapter are computer-generated, digitally authenticated and carry a Digital Identification Number. They are not issued with the Commissioner (Appeals)’s name, designation or signature. The final order is uploaded to the e-portal and communicated electronically to the appellant, respondent Commissioner and Field Operations Wing. Service into the appellant’s e-folder is treated as proper service under the cited statutory provisions.

An apparent mistake in the record can be rectified by the Appellate Unit through the system under section 57. If a filing, application or reply could not be made in time because the e-portal was unavailable due to technical failure confirmed by the Board, that failure is treated as sufficient cause for the relevant late filing. The exception depends on Board confirmation; a screenshot of an individual’s connectivity problem should not be assumed to satisfy it.

The chapter also limits the nature of further inquiry: the procedure does not authorise a remand for de novo consideration. Counsel should therefore prepare the appeal record, grounds and supporting documents with the expectation that the appellate decision will be made on the electronically available material, subject to the rule’s verification provisions.

07 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

Income-tax appeals: a separate draft, not final law

Draft S.R.O. 2136(I)/2026 proposes Chapter XIXA, rules 245A to 245M, in the Income Tax Rules, 2002. It would cover appeals under section 127 processed through the Centre under section 129A: appeals against orders of authorities of the Centre and other classes that the Board may specify by Gazette notification. Like the sales-tax chapter, it proposes electronic filing, automated allocation, anonymity of the Appellate Unit and Commissioner (Appeals), electronic submissions, video hearings, recorded proceedings and a written-submissions option.

The draft also preserves pending appeals before the existing Commissioner (Appeals) unless transferred, and the option to appeal directly to the Appellate Tribunal. Its commencement would be notified by the Board, potentially on different dates for different classes. The draft’s stay provisions refer to time limits in rule 76G; those cross-references should be checked against the applicable rules before a deadline is advised. The sales-tax chapter’s expressly stated two-working-day and seven-working-day timetable should not be transplanted into income-tax appeals without that verification.

The draft invites objections and suggestions within three days of publication in the Official Gazette. Because the Gazette publication date was not confirmed, the deadline cannot safely be calculated here. The proposal should not be described as a binding income-tax appeal procedure unless and until a final notification and commencement instrument are identified.

08 / REGULATORY ANALYSIS

What taxpayers, finance teams and counsel should do now

First, maintain a register of appeals and disputed orders that could fall within the National Faceless Centre’s jurisdiction. Record the tax, statute, order date, service date, current forum, limitation date, recovery status, grounds and available evidence. Do not assume that a pending appeal will transfer; monitor the Board’s commencement and class notifications and any specific transfer direction.

Second, make sure IRIS credentials, authorised representatives, email and mobile contact details are current and access is tested. Assign responsibility for checking the e-folder and portal notifications. Establish a response calendar that distinguishes the appeal deadline, respondent’s parawise comments, the appellant’s reply, hearing notice and any stay application. Save portal acknowledgements and timestamps in a matter folder accessible to the responsible team.

Third, prepare an indexed digital record before the first hearing: the impugned order, grounds, tax computation, invoices, ledgers, bank and withholding records, correspondence, statutory documents and any evidence supporting the factual or legal challenge. Use a file naming convention and retain the originals because the Commissioner may require verification. Counsel should reconcile the evidence to each ground rather than upload an unexplained bundle.

Fourth, decide the hearing strategy early. Where written submissions are appropriate, prepare the argument and evidence in a format that supports a written decision and preserve the right to reply to the respondent’s comments. Where video participation is required, arrange stable access, a responsible participant, authority to represent the taxpayer and a backup location. A taxpayer without internet should explore the specified Field Operations Wing facility rather than miss the hearing.

Finally, assess recovery separately from appeal merits. If recovery is threatened, identify the applicable statutory stay mechanism, payment condition and any existing order. Keep the stay request, supporting facts, respondent notice and order in the same deadline-controlled file. A change in hearing technology does not remove the need to establish limitation, grounds, evidence and interim protection under the law.

CHAMBERS / PRACTICAL VIEW

Prepare for a digital appellate record, not just a digital hearing.

The notified sales-tax and federal-excise chapter changes the channel, allocation, hearing and authentication process. Its start date remains controlled by a later Gazette notification. The income-tax proposal is still draft. Tax dispute teams should prepare their documents and access now, while checking the actual commencement and applicable class of appeal before changing filing or recovery strategy.

Related reading

FBR’s electronic scrutiny and IRIS intimation procedure · Preparing evidence and challenging an income-tax assessment · Direct appeal to the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal · When a tax demand may be challenged through a writ petition

Return to the Knowledge hub

OFFICIAL SOURCE / FINAL NOTIFICATIONS.R.O. 2134(I)/2026 — Chapter XIV-CA, Faceless Appeals

Federal Board of Revenue · Sales Tax Rules, 2006 · Notification dated 18 November 2026

READ OFFICIAL PDF ↗

Official source / draft income-tax amendments

Draft S.R.O. 2136(I)/2026 — Chapter XIXA, Faceless Appeals, Income Tax Rules, 2002. The draft proposes the framework described above; it is not a final notification.

FBR SROs and notifications directory

Publication note

The instrument date and legal status are distinguished from Gazette publication and commencement dates. The official documents govern; this briefing is general information and is not advice on a particular appeal.